The second and third parts of Sin in the Second City by Karen Abbott focus more on the business of prostitution and the downfall of the Everleigh Club in Chicago. Part two and three goes more in depth into the business of prostitution in Chicago. Also the last two parts of the book explains the downfall and closure of the Everleigh Club.
The Everleigh sisters faced some backlash from people from around the city and state such congressmen, religious leaders and law enforcement leaders. These groups pressed very hard to shutdown the Everleigh Club as well as putting an end to prostitution. After rigorous affects by congressmen, religious leaders and law enforcement leaders eventually it lead to the closure of the Everleigh Club and the placement of more strict laws on prostitution. From the start of the Everleigh Club, the Everleigh sister faced many obstacles during this time from many outside people. As the Everleigh Club became successful, more problems began to follow the Everleigh sisters.
One of the obstacles the sisters had to deal with was the present of Ernest Bell. Ernest Bell was a reverend who started his Midnight Mission so he could stop the activities going on in and around the Everleigh Club. Reverend Bell would hold nightly sermons outside the Everleigh Club to turn people away from the infamous brothel.
When they arrived on South Dearborn Street, the Everleigh Club before them, he halted and thrust out his arm.[1] Reverend Bell made it his mission to shut down every brothel in Chicago.
As the years began to past, things started to worsen for brothels and the prostitution business. We begin to see bills and laws starting to pass to put a strain on the prostitution business. The White Slave Traffic Act was a major component that contributed to the downfall of brothels and prostitution. On June 25 1910, the last day of the session, President William Howard Taft signed the White Slave Traffic Act into law.[2] Once this law was put into place we begin to see brothels and prostitution go downhill.
The final straw that lead to the closure of the Everleigh Club was Mayor Harrison of Chicago. Mayor Harrison made it a point to shut down the club for good. On October 24,1911 Mayor Harrison demanded the closure of the Everleigh Club. He wrote an order to close the club immediately. After tucking it into an envelope, the mayor called for a special messenger, who carried it immediately to the armory station and delivered it into the police chief’s hands. “Close the Everleigh Club’, the paper read. Effective immediately.[3] After the message was received by the police chief, it was the beginning to the end for the Everleigh Club.
The Everleigh sisters were tremendous business women and they were always planning their next business move. Even if the club closing the still ended up being okay. This Sisters had a plan and they stayed with it and they had one of the most successful businesses in the early 1900s.
1. Karen Abbott. Sin in the Second City: Madams, Ministers, Playboys, and the Battle for America's Soul. New York: Random House, 2007. Kindle Edition. Location 1931
2. Karen Abbott. Sin in the Second City: Madams, Ministers, Playboys, and the Battle for America's Soul. New York: Random House, 2007. Kindle Edition. Location 3857
3. Karen Abbott. Sin in the Second City: Madams, Ministers, Playboys, and the Battle for America's Soul. New York: Random House, 2007. Kindle Edition. Location 4232